Since the injury enforced retire­ment of Jerry Flan­nery in 2011, it is fair to say hooker has been something of a prob­lem pos­i­tion for Mun­ster.

At his peak in the mid-to-late 2000s, Flan­nery had a fair claim on being the best hooker in the world. Relent­less workrate, power in the scrum, pun­ish­ing ball car­ries and a level of accur­acy with his throw­ing that helped to make Ire­land’s lin­eout one of the most effi­cient in the game — Flan­nery was the full pack­age.

There were a lot of good hook­ers on the cir­cuit at the time, from John Smit, Bis­marck du Plessis from South Africa, Keven Meal­amu from New Zea­l­and, Aus­tralia’s Stephen Moore and Dimitri Szar­zewski of France, but Flan­nery was right up there.

Jerry Flannery
Jerry Flannery. Pic: Brendan Moran / SPORTSFILE

He was car­ry­ing on a rich Mun­ster leg­acy, the province hav­ing pro­duced some excep­tional hook­ers over the years.

From Pat ‘Pa’ Whelan to Ire­land cap­tains Terry King­ston and Keith Wood and onto Frankie Shee­han and Flan­nery, Mun­ster were well served in the No2 jer­sey from the 1970s right through to the 2010s.

Whelan had a lock on the Ire­land No2 jer­sey in the late 1970s, the Garry­owen man gain­ing a repu­ta­tion for innate tough­ness that stood him and whatever team he played for well — not least when part of an inspir­a­tional Mun­ster per­form­ance in their 12-0 win over the All Blacks in 1978.

1997797
The Munster front row, from left, Gerry McLoughlin, Pat Whelan and Brendan O’Connor prepare for a scrum during the Interprovincial match between Leinster and Munster at Lansdowne Road in Dublin. Pic: Ray McManus/Sportsfile

Dolphin man King­ston was cut from the same cloth and his qual­ity was quickly recog­nised by Ire­land, with King­ston play­ing in three World Cups between 1987 and 1995 (when he was cap­tain) as well as lead­ing Mun­ster to a fam­ous win over the world cham­pion Walla­bies in Cork in 1992.

Wood, the first player to be hon­oured with the world player of the year award in 2001, is regarded as one of the best hook­ers to have ever played the game, with Shee­han an elite under­study for province and coun­try.

And, even then, in the post-Flan­nery era from 2011 to the present day, it was not as if Mun­ster had ter­rible hooker options to choose from. The likes of Declan Var­ley, Mike Sherry, Duncan Casey, Niall Scan­nell, Kevin O’Byrne, Rhys Mar­shall and Diar­muid Bar­ron are all decent oper­at­ors and picked up some caps here and there — it was just that they were not at the level that had gone before and not at a level to con­sist­ently nail down a spot in the Ire­land team.

Rónan Kelleher, centre, and Dan Sheehan of Ireland leaves the pitch after the first test between South Africa and Ireland at Loftus Versfeld Stadium in Pretoria, South Africa. Pic: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile
Rónan Kelleher, centre, and Dan Sheehan of Ireland leaves the pitch after the first test between South Africa and Ireland at Loftus Versfeld Stadium in Pretoria, South Africa. Pic: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile

Over the last 15 years, the Ire­land hooker spot has been shared between Ulster (Rory Best and Rob Her­ring) and Lein­ster (Richardt Strauss, Ronan Kelle­her and Dan Shee­han) with Con­nacht’s Dave Hef­fernan offer­ing back up as needed.

The Mun­ster lads play­ing hooker have not really figured, hence the ‘prob­lem pos­i­tion’ tag. It is why the province chased former Walla­bies cap­tain Stephen Moore so hard around 2015 and were so frus­trated when the move fell through.

But now, even though we are only three games into the sea­son, there is com­pel­ling evid­ence that Mun­ster have finally found a solu­tion to their hooker prob­lem and have found a player cap­able of liv­ing up to the leg­acy of Flan­nery and those who went before.

Munster marnus van der merwe
Marnus van der Merwe of Munster. Pic: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile

When it was announced earlier this year that Mun­ster had recruited 29-year-old Marnus van der Merwe from fel­low URC club Scar­lets, it was not exactly head­line news.

A solid sign­ing, was the gen­eral con­sensus among pun­dits and sup­port­ers but, in truth, that was something of a kick to touch because not a whole lot was known about the former Free State Chee­tahs No2 bey­ond the fact he was well regarded in the off-Broad­way environs of Llan­elli in south Wales.

There are cer­tain assump­tions you make when it comes to South African front rows — they will be big, phys­ical and hard work­ing and will excel at the set-piece.

Van der Merwe ticks all those boxes. Like Flan­nery, his scrum­ma­ging and lin­eout throw­ing are top-notch, and he is always look­ing for work on the pitch. What has exceeded expect­a­tions is the South African’s abil­ity around the park.

For a man of his size (6ft2in, 18.5st), the former Scar­lets man is very mobile and his rugby is evid­ent in his angles of run­ning and abil­ity to trans­port him­self to the place where he is most needed in the fast­est pos­sible time.

3584290
Marnus van der Merwe during the United Rugby Championship match between Munster and Vodacom Bulls at Thomond Park in Limerick. Pic: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile

But it is the work of the three­times-capped Spring­bok at the break­down that has been most arrest­ing. Van der Merwe’s com­bin­a­tion of speed, tim­ing, wide stance style and supreme upper body strength makes him a fero­cious pro­spect for the oppos­i­tion when the battle for pos­ses­sion com­mences on the ground.

The Mun­ster oper­a­tion has received its share of jus­ti­fied cri­ti­cism in recent times, not least for its poor recruit­ment, with ex-play­ers queuing up to ques­tion some ‘dud’ sign­ings.

But they look to have got it very right with Marnus van der Merwe and in a pos­i­tion that for years was notice­ably lack­ing in sparkle, Mun­ster have got them­selves a gem.